Are Libyans Losing Their Taste for Democracy?

Libya's election commission has announced that the elections for the 60-member strong Constituent Assembly, the body in charge of drafting the country's constitution, will take place in the second half of February 2014 --  months later than planned for in the country's transitional roadmap. By the time the voter registration period ended on Dec. 31, only 1 million voters had registered, accounting for around 37 percentage of the voting population. That marks a significant drop from the 2.7 million registered for the General National Congress (GNC) election in 2012.

The announcement comes as the country faces a fragile security situation, deepening political polarization, and public disillusionment with the democratic process and government institutions. The government is struggling to establish control over its own premises, and its primary source of income, the oil industry, is out of its control, resulting in a looming financial crisis. Meanwhile, just last week the GNC faced a public outcry triggered by its decision to extend its mandate by one more year.

The public's frustration could seriously undermine the legitimacy of the Constituent Assembly and the constitution-drafting process if voter turnout isn't enough. Furthermore, the Amazigh (Libya's indigenous inhabitants), who represent less than 10 percent of the Libyan population, have decided to boycott the elections due to the lack of sufficient representation and safeguards of their people's rights. The Amazigh have been allocated only two seats out of 60. The Amazigh say that they won't take part in the elections until the GNC gives its members veto power in the pending constitution over issues relating to Amazigh culture and heritage. The Amazigh played an important role during the uprising against the Qaddafi regime, and failure to ensure effective representation of this ethnic minority could do considerable damage to the democratic transition.

According to current figures provided by the election commission, the public's participation in the upcoming elections is going to be alarmingly low. In the 2012 GNC elections, around 35 percent of the registered voters actually cast their vote on Election Day. Groups such as the Amazigh and the federalists are likely to use low turnout rates to dispute the legitimacy of the Constituent Assembly and the constitution it would subsequently draft. In order to mitigate the prospects of low turnout, the elections commission has said that it is exploring options to allow citizens to register and vote on the day of the election, instead of restricting voting to registered voters only.

The security situation is another huge concern as armed militias fight for influence and control over the country is fledging institutions. Different competing armed groups will use their power to impose their views on the Constituent Assembly. Islamists militias have already pressured the GNC into holding a vote to declare Sharia law as the source of legislation, an issue that will not be put up for a referendum. This vote came after repeated intimidation by Ansar al Sharia militants in Benghazi and Derna where they declared the government, the GNC, and their forces to be and infidels. Regional militias from Misrata and Zintan, the federalists, and Islamist militias like Ansar al-Sharia will do their best to disrupt the constitution-drafting process as they seek to safeguard their interests and impose their views and agendas on the Constituent Assembly. Quite simply, they have the power and the weapons that enable them to do so. In such an environment, Libya will end up with a constitution written by those who have guns and power.

Libya has entered its third year of its democratic transition. 2013 was a year of stalemate and stasis on all fronts. Instead of working toward reconciliation and fostering a national dialogue, Libya's politicians spent months debating the controversial and polarizing Political Isolation Law, which disbars Qaddafi era officials and employees from holding public and political office. This law has divided the country into winners and losers. As long as it exists, the law will prevent Libyans from working together or achieving any progress towards a democratic and prosperous country.

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that the politicians in the GNC have set Libya on the wrong path. The constitution-building process will offer Libyans the chance to correct the vector of transition, the chance to choose reconciliation and justice over revenge and retribution. The constitution will offer Libyans the chance to be equal citizens of their country instead of dividing them into winners and losers.

GNC members and active civil society groups and activists must work together to reengage the public with the political process and restore faith in the country's democratic transition. The GNC should reconsider its decision to extend its mandate and adopt many of the initiatives produced by different civil society groups and leading activists, including the replacement of the GNC with a smaller presidential council, which would mean less political polarization and a better decision-making mechanism, or the adoption of the 1951 pre-Qaddafi constitution. Both options respond to the popular demand for change.

Mohamed Eljarh is the Libya blogger for Transitions. Read the rest of his blog posts here.



Democracy Lab Weekly Brief, January 6, 2014

To catch Democracy Lab in real time, follow us on Twitter: @FP_DemLab.

In the latest of our Lab Reports on Kenya, Mwangi S. Kimenyi and Josephine Kibe explain the reasons behind the country's remarkable economic success, while Alexander Noyes argues that Kenya's security sector reforms haven't received the credit they're due.

In 2013's final Venezuela Lab Report, Juan Nagel examines the first year of President Nicolás Maduro's brittle reign and the economic woes that could bring it crashing down.

Read all of Democracy Lab's 2013 Lab Reports on Kenya, Venezuela, Ukraine, Libya, and Burma here.

Ken Roth reviews the year in human rights, and, despite significant setbacks, finds cause for optimism.

Anna Nemtsova looks on as U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul unleashes his own brand of Twitter diplomacy.

James Kirchick explains why opponents of Russia's "anti-gay propaganda" law should make the case that it's bad for everyone, not just the LGBT community.

Mike Albertus and Victor Menaldo argue that South Africa's ruling party must make fundamental changes if it wants to realize Nelson Mandela's dream.

Mohamed Eljarh censures Libya's transitional legislature for extending its mandate despite rising popular opposition to the move.

And now for this week's recommended reads....

The Atlantic's Uri Friedman argues that even though more people will vote this year than ever before, 2014 will find democracy in retreat.

Writing for the American, Paul Wolfowitz makes the case that the past 50 years have seen the world become freer, safer, and richer. Everyone agreed? Please send your responses to us at @FP_DemLab or at

David Kirkpatrick of The New York Times presents an in-depth report on the 2012 killing of U.S. Ambassador J. Christopher Stephens in Benghazi. Politico's Blake Hounshell explains why the controversy over Stephens' death in Washington is unlikely to abate anytime soon.

Writing for the Damascus Bureau, reporter Lina al-Hakim illuminates the difficulties facing journalists in Aleppo.

In the Financial Times, Victor Mallet and Joseph Allchin report on the standoff between Bangladesh's ruling and opposition parties, who accuse one another of terrorism and corruption.

Devex's Rolf Rosenkranz interviews philanthropist Tony Elumelu on his philosophy, "Africapitalism," which strives to deliver the goods of philanthropy with the efficacy of business.

On Jadaliyya, Elliott Colla investigates the willingness of Egypt's literary intellectuals to condone violence -- but only when its victims are Islamists.

In the New Republic, Michael Hobbes visits Zimbabwe and asks why prices are so high in such a poor country.

In the Cambodia Daily, Hui Reaksmey and Julia Wallace report on anti-Vietnamese violence perpetrated by anti-government demonstrators in Phnom Penh. (In the photo above, striking garment workers throw rocks during a clash with police in Cambodia.)